Database Search Result Details

First Name HAROLD
Last Name MORAN
Decision Date 1/27/1989
Docket Number 24-88-178
ALJ NK
Respondent MARION COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type SERV
Job Title BUS OPERATOR
Topics SELECTION
Primary Issues Competency Testing; Duty Classification
Outcome DENIED
Statutes 18A-4-8B(B)
Related Cases
Keywords
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court Grievant appealed to Marion County, 3/2/89, Civil Action #92-C-51; Affirmed 9/29/93
Supreme Court
Synopsis GRIEVANT IS EMPLOYED AS A BUS OPERATOR AND ALLEGED A VIOLATION OF W.VA. CODE, 18A-4-8B WHEN HE WAS NOT SELECTED FOR A POSITION AS DIRECTOR OF TRANSPORTATION. GRIEVANT AND OTHER OUT-OF-CLASSIFICATION APPLICANTS WERE GIVEN A SKILLS TEST TO DETERMINE WHETHER THEY POSSESSED QUALIFICATIONS DEEMED NECESSARY FOR THE POSITIONS. DECISION: W.VA. CODE, 18A-4-8B(A) REQUIRES THAT WHEN NO PERSONS HOLDING A CLASSIFICATION TITLE FOR A VACANT POSITION ARE AVAILABLE, WHO SHALL QUALIFY BY MEETING THE STATUTORY DEFINITION OF THE JOB TITLE. A BASIC SKILLS TEST AND OTHER UNIFORMLY ADMINISTERED SELECTION PROCEDURES ARE REASONABLE MEANS BY WHICH TO IDENTIFY QUALIFIED APPLICANTS. DENIED; GRIEVANT WAS DETERMINED NOT QUALIFIED BASED ON HIS TEST SCORES AND HAS FAILED TO PROVE THAT HE WAS ENTITLED TO THE POSITION AS A MATTER OF LAW OR THAT THE SCHOOL BOARD ACTED IMPROPERLY.

Back to Results Search Again