Database Search Result Details

First Name GENE
Last Name FARMER
Decision Date 4/25/1990
Docket Number 89-23-673/A,B
ALJ RN
Respondent LOGAN COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type PROF
Job Title TEACHER
Topics HARASSMENT; REPRISAL
Primary Issues Letter of reprimand; evaluation based on impermissible factors; insubordination
Outcome GRANTED
Statutes 18-29-2(N);18-29-2(P);18-29-2(S)
Related Cases GILL V. COMMERCE; 351 S.E.2D 58 (W.VA. 1986)
Keywords HARASSMENT; REPRISAL; INSUBORDINATION
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court
Supreme Court
Synopsis RESPONDENT HAS MET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF IN SHOWING THAT GRIEVANT WAS INSUBORDINATE IN FAILING TO TURN IN THE REQUESTED GRADE DISTRIBUTION SHEETS ON TWO OCCASIONS. GRIEVANT HAS MET HIS BURDEN OF PROOF IN SHOWING THAT RESPONDENT FAILED TO FOLLOW ITS OWN POLICY REGARDING EVALUATIONS AND THAT RESPONDENT CONSIDERED IMPERMISSIBLE FACTORS IN ITS EVALUATION OF HIM. GRIEVANT HAS NOT MET HIS BURDEN OF PROOF IN ESTABLISHING THAT RESPONDENT HAS ENGAGED IN HARASSMENT OR REPRISAL AGAINST HIM.

Back to Results Search Again