Database Search Result Details

First Name ALLEN
Last Name MCCROSKEY
Decision Date 10/31/1988
Docket Number 51-88-116
ALJ SK
Respondent WEBSTER COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type PROF
Job Title TEACHER
Topics DISMISSAL
Primary Issues Whether Grievant acted in an immoral manner by engaging in conduct not in conformity with accepted principals of right and wrong.
Outcome DENIED
Statutes 18A-2-8
Related Cases 158 W.VA. 1067, 216 S.E.2D 554 (1975); GOLDEN, 285 S.E.2D 665; ROVELLO V. LEWIS COUNTY; ALLISON V. KANAWHA COUNTY; GROB V. TAYLOR CBOE
Keywords IMMORALITY; DRESS; SUGGESTIVE; MORAL; PARENTAL COMPLAINT; CLOTHING
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court Grievant appealed to Kanawha County, Civil Action #88-AA-300, 11/6/91; Reversed
Supreme Court Writ of Cert filed; settled
Synopsis The term 'immorality' is an imprecise work which means different things to different people, but in essence connotes conduct which is not in conformity with accepted values of right and wrong behavior; contrary to the moral code of the community; wicked; and especially not in conformance with the accepted standards of proper sexual behavior. A teacher may be dismissed without direct proof of an adverse effect of the alleged misconduct where the conduct directly involves minor students and is patently inappropriate. Such conduct is presumed to have an adverse effect on the students, teachers and staff of the school. Grievance denied: the BOE has satisfied the burden of proof set out in Golden and has acted in good faith in attempting to preserve the integrity of the school system.

Back to Results Search Again