Database Search Result Details

First Name CURTIS
Last Name MEEKS
Decision Date 7/30/1987
Docket Number 20-87-016-1
ALJ LC
Respondent KANAWHA COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type SERV
Job Title CUSTODIAN IV
Topics SELECTION
Primary Issues Past Evaluations
Outcome DENIED
Statutes 18A-4-8B
Related Cases DORSEY V. NICHOLAS
Keywords SUBJECTIVE; SELECTION; EVALUATIONS
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court Grievant appealed to Kanawha County 3/5/91, Civil Action #87-AA-237, Affirmed
Supreme Court
Synopsis G APPLIED FOR A CUSTODIAN IV POSITION AT ANOTHER HIGH SCHOOL. THE PERSON INITIALLY SELECTED RESIGNED SHORTLY THEREAFTER AND THE POSITION WAS NOT READVERTISED. FOLLOWING INTERVIEWS THE LEAST SENIOR APPLICANT WAS SELECTED. G ARGUED HIS PAST NEGATIVE EVALUATIONS SHOULD NOT HAVE USED AGAINST HIM AND ALSO RAISED A QUESTION ABOUT THE SUBJECTIVITY OF THE INTERVIEW PROCESS. THE HEARING EXAMINER FOUND THE INTERVIEW WAS NOT THE DECISIVE FACTOR AND THE DISPARITIES IN PAST EVALUATIONS JUSTIFIED THE SELECTION.

Back to Results Search Again