Database Search Result Details

First Name SARAH
Last Name MCCOURT
Decision Date 9/29/1988
Docket Number 51-88-047
ALJ SK
Respondent WEBSTER COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type PROF
Job Title TEACHER/GIRLS TRACK COACH
Topics SELECTION
Primary Issues Application of Seniority
Outcome GRANTED
Statutes 18A-4-8b
Related Cases 346 S.E.2D 798 (W.VA. 1986); 341 S.E.2D 685
Keywords QUALIFICATIONS; SELECTION, SENIORITY; FAVORITISM
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court
Supreme Court
Synopsis Grievant alleges favoritism in the selection of Coordinator of Athletic Activities as the successful candidate was the sister of the superintendent and seniority did not factor into the Board's selection. Merely ascertaining that all candidates meet the minimum qualifications for a position is not enough to trigger reliance upon seniority to fill the vacancy. Before seniority is to be considered two or more candidates must be equally qualified and not such determination has been made in this instance. Grievance granted and BOE is ordered to reevaluate the applicants.

Back to Results Search Again