Database Search Result Details

First Name MOSS
Last Name BURGESS
Decision Date 8/22/1988
Docket Number 23-88-046
ALJ JW
Respondent LOGAN COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION
Employment Type PROF
Job Title TEACHER
Topics REPRIMAND
Primary Issues WARNINGS, DISCIPLINE
Outcome GRANTED
Statutes
Related Cases
Keywords UNIFORMITY IN DISCIPLINE
Intermediate Court of Appeals
Circuit Court
Supreme Court
Synopsis G, HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER, STATED IN THE PRESENCE OF TWO TEACHERS AND HIS ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL THAT HE SCHOOL SECRETARY WAS LAZY. HE RECEIVED A WRITTEN WARNING, WHICH WAS PLACED IN HIS PERSONNEL FILE, TO THE EFFECT THAT THE COMMENT COULD HAVE 'POSSIBLE REPERCUSSIONS' NEGATIVE TO HARMONY AT THE SCHOOL. PREVIOUS OCCASION, ANOTHER TEACHER DURING A FACULTY MEETING, HAD STATED THAT CERTAIN UNIDENTIFIED TEACHERS WERE LAZY; SHE WAS NOT REPRIMANDED. DECISION: BOE POLICY PROVIDES THAT EMPLOYEES MAY BE DISCIPLINED BY WRITTEN WARNINGS; HOWEVER, THIS POLICY MUST BE APPLIED UNIFORMLY. THERE IS NO SIGNIFICANT DISTINCTION BETWEEN G COMMENT AND OTHER TEACHER'S. WRITTEN WARNING ORDERED REMOVED FROM FILE. FURTHER, IGNORING G COMMENT WOULD HAVE BEEN MORE CONSISTENT WITH 'MAINTAINING HARMONY,' SINCE THE ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL REPORTED THE COMMENT TO THE SECRETARY. CODE S18-29-2(M) CITED BUT NOT RELIED UPON. GRANTED.

Back to Results Search Again